Common Reasons Medical Research Manuscripts Get Rejected
Why journals reject medical manuscripts, from poor fit and weak methods to overstated conclusions, and what you can do before and after a rejection.
Rejection is a normal part of publishing; most researchers experience it many times. Understanding the common reasons helps you avoid the avoidable ones and respond sensibly when it happens. Studies of editors' and reviewers' decisions, such as those by Bordage and by Pierson, highlight similar themes.
Rejected before peer review ("desk rejection")
Editors often reject quickly when:
- The topic is outside the journal's scope or of limited interest to its readers.
- The author instructions were not followed (format, word count, structure, missing statements).
- The message is unclear from the title and abstract.
- The language makes the work hard to follow.
- Ethics approval or consent is not reported.
Rejected after peer review
Common reasons relate to the science:
- Weak study design for the question asked.
- Inadequate or unjustified sample size, making results imprecise.
- Incomplete or inappropriate statistical analysis.
- Conclusions not supported by the data, such as causal claims from cross-sectional data.
- Little that is new, without explaining why replication in a new setting matters.
- Poor reporting, so reviewers cannot judge the methods.
Prevention checklist
| Before submitting, check | |
|---|---|
| The journal's scope and recent articles match your study | |
| The title and abstract state the question, design and main result | |
| Methods follow the relevant reporting guideline (STROBE, CONSORT, etc.) | |
| Sample size and analysis are justified | |
| Conclusions match the design and data | |
| Ethics, consent, funding and conflicts are stated | |
| The text has been read by a colleague outside your team |
After a rejection
- Read the comments calmly, ideally after a day or two.
- Separate fixable problems from fit problems. Improve the manuscript wherever the comments are valid, even if you submit elsewhere.
- Choose the next journal with the comments in mind, and reformat to its instructions.
- If the decision allows resubmission or appeal, respond point by point, politely, showing exactly what changed.
Responding to reviewers (for revisions)
- Thank the reviewers and answer every comment.
- Quote each comment, then give your response and the location of the change.
- If you disagree, explain why with evidence, respectfully.
Key takeaways
- Many rejections are about fit, format or clarity, which you can control.
- Scientific rejections usually point to design, analysis, reporting or overstated conclusions.
- Use reporting guidelines and a pre-submission checklist.
- Treat reviewer comments as free advice for the next submission.
References
- Bordage G. Reasons reviewers reject and accept manuscripts: the strengths and weaknesses in medical education reports. Acad Med. 2001;76(9):889–896.
- Pierson DJ. The top 10 reasons why manuscripts are not accepted for publication. Respir Care. 2004;49(10):1246–1252.
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. icmje.org
This article is for education. Always follow the requirements of your university, guide, ethics committee and target journal.