How to Prepare a Medical Manuscript for Journal Submission
Turn a thesis into a journal manuscript: choosing a journal, IMRaD structure, authorship, reporting guidelines and the cover letter.
A dissertation and a journal article are different documents. A thesis may run to a hundred pages; most original articles have strict word limits. Turning your work into a publishable manuscript means selecting, condensing and following one journal's instructions exactly.
Step 1: Choose the right journal
- Scope and audience: does the journal publish your type of study and topic? Read a few recent articles.
- Indexing: check where the journal is indexed (for example, MEDLINE/PubMed) and that this matches your requirements.
- Article type and limits: original article, brief report or short communication; word count, number of tables and references.
- Costs and timelines: article processing charges, if any, and typical review times.
- Legitimacy: be careful of journals that promise very fast publication for a fee. The Think. Check. Submit. checklist helps you assess a journal.
Step 2: Restructure into IMRaD
| Section | What to keep from your thesis |
|---|---|
| Introduction | A few focused paragraphs ending with the objective |
| Methods | Essential details only, following the journal's reporting guideline |
| Results | Primary outcomes and key secondary results; 3–5 tables or figures |
| Discussion | Main findings, comparison with key studies, strengths, limitations, implications |
Cut the review of literature to what is needed for context. Move detailed tables to supplementary material if the journal allows it.
Step 3: Follow the reporting guideline
Use the checklist for your design: STROBE (observational), CONSORT (randomised trials), STARD (diagnostic accuracy) or PRISMA (systematic reviews). Many journals ask you to upload the completed checklist.
Step 4: Get authorship right
The ICMJE recommends that authorship is based on four criteria together: substantial contribution to the work; drafting or critically revising it; final approval of the version to be published; and agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work. Others who helped can be acknowledged. Agree on the author order early.
Step 5: Complete the required statements
- Ethics committee approval and informed consent
- Trial registration (for clinical trials)
- Funding and conflicts of interest
- Data availability, if the journal asks
- Any use of writing or statistical assistance, as the journal's policy requires
Step 6: Prepare the files
- Title page with all authors, affiliations and the corresponding author
- Structured abstract within the word limit
- Main text formatted exactly as the author instructions say
- References in the journal's style
- Tables as editable text, figures in the required resolution and format
- A short cover letter explaining what the study adds and why it suits the journal
Common mistakes
- Submitting the thesis format with minimal changes.
- Ignoring the journal's word limits and reference style.
- Adding authors who do not meet authorship criteria, or leaving out those who do.
- Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at once.
Key takeaways
- Pick a legitimate journal whose scope fits your study.
- Condense the thesis into a focused IMRaD article.
- Follow the reporting guideline and the author instructions exactly.
- Use ICMJE criteria for authorship and complete every required statement.
References
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. icmje.org
- EQUATOR Network. Reporting guidelines for main study types. equator-network.org
- Think. Check. Submit. thinkchecksubmit.org
This article is for education. Always follow the requirements of your university, guide, ethics committee and target journal.